Fansly vs OnlyFans
Last updated
Fansly and OnlyFans both keep 20% of creator revenue, so the fee is not what separates them. Fansly supports multiple simultaneous subscription tiers and a free follow, while OnlyFans uses a single subscription price. OnlyFans has a far larger audience. For most creators the practical answer is OnlyFans first, Fansly second.
Fansly vs OnlyFans at a glance
| Feature | Fansly | OnlyFans |
|---|---|---|
| Platform cut | 20% | 20% |
| Creator share | 80% | 80% |
| Subscription pricing | Multiple tiers at once | One price per account |
| Free follow | Yes, built in | Free accounts possible, no separate follow tier |
| In-app discovery | Explore feed and hashtags | Very limited |
| Audience size | Not published; every estimate is far smaller | 377.5 million registered fan accounts (Fenix International FY2024 filing) |
| Exclusivity required | No | No |
| Payout currency | USD | USD |
Which one pays more?
For almost every creator, OnlyFans pays more in absolute terms, because the audience is larger by an order of magnitude. The 20% cut is identical, so the difference is traffic rather than economics.
Fansly earns its place differently. The tier system lets you sell a cheap entry level and a premium level on the same account, which is hard to replicate on OnlyFans. The free follow gives you a list of people you can market to before they ever pay. Those are structural advantages, and they do not add up to a bigger platform.
Can you run both at the same time?
Yes. Neither platform requires exclusivity and the same content library serves both. Running both is the common pattern among creators we manage, and the main reason is not income. It is that a single platform can change a policy or lose a payment processor, and an account that exists in one place has no fallback when that happens.
What we have observed across accounts is that a second platform adds real income without doubling anything. Treating Fansly as a full second salary sets an expectation the numbers do not support.
Which should a new creator start with?
Start where the audience is, which is OnlyFans, then add Fansly once the first account has a routine that runs without you. Launching both in the same week usually means neither gets the posting cadence it needs.
What is Fansly covers the platform itself. Fansly payout methods covers how the money actually reaches you, which differs more than the headline split suggests.
Frequently asked questions
Does Fansly or OnlyFans pay creators more?
OnlyFans pays most creators more in absolute terms because its audience is far larger, not because its rates are better. Fansly and OnlyFans both keep 20% of creator revenue. Fansly’s advantage is structural: multiple subscription tiers on one account and a free follow tier that can be marketed to later.
Can a creator run Fansly and OnlyFans at the same time?
A creator can run Fansly and OnlyFans simultaneously, because neither platform requires exclusivity and the same content library serves both. The main reason to do so is resilience rather than income, since one platform can change a policy or lose a payment processor. A second platform usually adds meaningful income without doubling total earnings.
Should a creator start on Fansly or OnlyFans first?
Most creators should start on OnlyFans and add Fansly as a second account. OnlyFans has a much larger paying audience, while Fansly offers multiple subscription tiers and a free follow that OnlyFans does not. Both platforms take 20% of creator revenue and neither requires exclusivity, so running both is possible once the first account has a routine.